Is Arch Manning Good? Yes, but He Isn't a Top-Five Pick Yet

Arch Manning keeps winning close games for Texas, but the numbers say he's good, not great. I dug into his stats, ESPN's QBR and the sack problem holding him back.

SummarizeChatGPTClaudeGeminiGrok
Is Arch Manning Good? Yes, but He Isn't a Top-Five Pick Yet
Image: Image: Up in The Rafters

Arch Manning threw three interceptions at LSU on Nov. 14, 2026, and still won the game. Down 21-16 with 2:19 left, he took Texas 58 yards, converted three third downs (two of them with his legs) and hit Raleek Brown for a 4-yard touchdown with three seconds on the clock. Texas won 22-21 in Baton Rouge and moved to 8-2 (ESPN, Texas Athletics).

That game is the whole Arch Manning debate in one night. He was 19 of 35 for 174 yards, and he made the plays that mattered at the end.

Is Arch Manning good? Yes. He's a good college quarterback who wins close games and has Texas in the playoff race. He isn't great yet. Through 10 games in 2026 he ranks 51st of 137 qualified FBS quarterbacks in ESPN's schedule-adjusted QBR, and he's lost more expected points to sacks than all but one of them. My take: he's good enough to win a playoff game this year, and he should play one more college season before the NFL.

Arch Manning's Stats: 2025 vs. 2026

These are from his ESPN game log. The 2025 line includes the Citrus Bowl win over Michigan.

SeasonGamesTeam recordComp-AttComp %Pass yardsYards/attPass TDINTSacks
20251310-3248-40461.4%3,1637.826723
2026108-2187-28964.7%2,1987.6191031

The completion percentage is up. Almost everything else is flat or worse. He's already thrown more interceptions in 10 games than he did in 13 last year, and he's been sacked 31 times, which is 3.1 a game. Last year it was 1.8.

He also isn't putting up big volume. As of Nov. 15, 2026, his 2,198 passing yards don't crack ESPN's top 50 in FBS, and his 19 touchdown passes have him tied for 45th.

Where He Ranks Against the Other Big-Name QBs

ESPN's Total QBR adjusts for schedule, which helps a guy who plays in the SEC. Here's how Manning compares with the quarterbacks who were supposed to be in his tier coming into the season, using ESPN's college QBR table as of Nov. 15, 2026.

QuarterbackTeamSchedule-adjusted QBRRank (of 137)
Darian MensahMiami88.71
Julian SayinOhio State86.33
Gunner StocktonGeorgia85.14
CJ CarrNotre Dame83.96
Sam LeavittLSU83.68
Arch ManningTexas62.651

That gap is big. Before the season, Carr was the Heisman favorite at +750 and Manning was right behind him at +800 at BetMGM, per USA Today. Carr has played like the guy the odds said he'd be. Manning hasn't.

His unadjusted QBR is even lower, 56.5, which ranks 96th. So the schedule is actually helping his number, not hurting it.

The Real Problem Is the Sacks

ESPN's QBR breaks a quarterback's value into pieces. Manning's passing is fine, 57th of 137. His running is 55th. Where he falls apart is sacks: he's lost 14.7 expected points on them, second-worst among all 137 qualified quarterbacks. Only Byrum Brown has lost more.

Some of that is on the offensive line. Not all of it. Tony Pauline passed along an evaluation from a source who has covered Manning since his freshman year, and it lines up with the numbers: that his footwork hurts his accuracy on short and intermediate throws, and that he "doesn't see it," meaning he doesn't anticipate the rush or where defenders are going to be (College Football Network).

Six sacks at Tennessee. Five against Florida. Five more against Mississippi State. I think the sacks and the interceptions come from the same place: not seeing it fast enough. That doesn't get easier in the NFL.

The Best Case for Arch: He Wins the Close Ones

Here's where I have to give him credit, because this is the strongest argument against me. Texas has played six one-score games in 2026, and Manning is 4-2 in them.

OpponentResultManning's line
Ohio StateW 24-2323-37, 195 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT
at TennesseeW 20-1714-19, 201 yards, 0 TD, 1 INT, 6 sacks
OklahomaL 27-2419-31, 260 yards, 3 TD, 2 INT
FloridaL 27-2414-20, 173 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT, 5 sacks
Ole MissW 34-2718-30, 212 yards, 1 TD, 2 INT, 2 rush TD
at LSUW 22-2119-35, 174 yards, 1 TD, 3 INT, 1 rush TD

Beating Ohio State, Tennessee on the road, Ole Miss and LSU on the road is a real résumé, and it's why Texas was No. 6 in the Nov. 10 College Football Playoff rankings. He's also been better lately: nine total touchdowns and two interceptions in the three games before LSU, with Texas winning all three.

He's done this before, too. Over the last eight games of 2025, Texas went 7-1, and he completed 62.1% of his passes for 2,012 yards, 15 touchdowns and just two interceptions. CBS Sports pointed out he was one of only three FBS quarterbacks in 2025 with 3,500 total yards, 25 passing touchdowns and 10 rushing touchdowns.

So he's good. A bad quarterback doesn't go 4-2 in one-score games against that schedule. But "wins close games" and "is a top-five pick" are different things. The best quarterbacks usually don't let the games get that close.

Will Texas Make the College Football Playoff?

I think so. Texas is 8-2 with Arkansas at home on Nov. 21 and a trip to Texas A&M on Nov. 27 (ESPN schedule). Every one of ESPN's 12 experts put Texas in their projected 12-team field after Week 11, in spots ranging from No. 5 to No. 10 (ESPN). ESPN's Heather Dinich wrote that the LSU win cemented Texas' place in the race "barring a catastrophic upset over the next two weeks" (ESPN).

If you need a refresher on byes and seeding, here's how the 12-team College Football Playoff works. And this is one more reason I think a 24-team playoff is a good idea: the more teams that get in, the fewer seasons hang on one late throw in Death Valley.

Can Manning win a playoff game? Yes, against most of that bracket. Can he win three or four in a row against the Georgias and Utahs? That's where the sack problem and the turnovers would catch up with him.

Should Arch Manning Enter the 2027 NFL Draft?

No. I think he should play one more college season.

He hasn't announced anything. Steve Sarkisian said in June that he "wouldn't be surprised" if Manning came back for a fifth season in 2027, and CBS Sports draft writer Ryan Wilson wrote on Oct. 14 that he had already dropped Manning from his first mock draft of the fall (CBS Sports). Wilson also noted Manning had just 20 career starts five games into 2026. He's started all five games since, so he's at 25. That's not many for a guy who entered the season as the betting favorite to go No. 1 overall, per CBS Sports.

Where he plays that extra season is a separate question. There's been a lot of transfer talk, but it's all speculation right now, and I'm not going to pretend I know where he'll be in 2027. What I do know is that another year of film where the sacks come down would do more for his draft stock than anything he can do in the next two months. If you want to know how the draft order itself gets set, I broke down how NFL draft picks are determined.

Questions People Are Asking

Is Arch Manning good? Yes. He's 8-2 as Texas' starter in 2026 and 4-2 in one-score games. He's not elite yet: he ranks 51st of 137 qualified FBS quarterbacks in ESPN's schedule-adjusted QBR as of Nov. 15, 2026.

What are Arch Manning's stats in 2026? Through 10 games: 187 of 289 (64.7%) for 2,198 yards, 19 touchdowns and 10 interceptions, plus three rushing touchdowns. He's been sacked 31 times.

How did Arch Manning play against LSU? He went 19 of 35 for 174 yards, one touchdown and three interceptions, ran for a score, and threw the game-winning 4-yard touchdown to Raleek Brown with three seconds left in a 22-21 win on Nov. 14, 2026.

What year is Arch Manning in college? Texas lists him as a senior in 2026, his fourth season. Sarkisian said in June that he wouldn't be surprised if Manning returned for a fifth season in 2027.

Is Arch Manning entering the 2027 NFL Draft? He hasn't announced a decision as of Nov. 15, 2026.

Is Arch Manning related to Peyton Manning? Yes. Peyton and Eli Manning are his uncles, Archie Manning is his grandfather, and his parents are Cooper and Ellen Manning.

Will Texas make the College Football Playoff? It's likely. Texas is 8-2, was No. 6 in the Nov. 10 CFP rankings, and all 12 ESPN experts had the Longhorns in their projected field after Week 11.

Final Thoughts

Is he overrated? No. Arch Manning is a good quarterback who has Texas headed for the playoff, and nobody wins four one-score games against that schedule by accident. But the numbers say he's closer to the 50th-best quarterback in the country than the best, and the sacks are the reason. Fix that, and the hype finally matches the player. I just don't think it happens before April.

How I put this together: season and game stats are from Arch Manning's ESPN game logs for 2025 and 2026. QBR figures and the sack breakdown are from ESPN's college QBR data, pulled Nov. 15, 2026. Game details from ESPN's LSU recap; playoff outlook from ESPN's Week 11 projections; draft context from CBS Sports; preseason Heisman odds from USA Today (BetMGM). Everything is current as of Nov. 15, 2026.

Sources

About the author

Matthew Finlayson

Founder and Editor

Matt's first sports memories are Kobe dropping 81, LaDainian Tomlinson making defenders look silly, and Derek Jeter somehow always coming through in October. He's been hooked ever since.

Think a number is off? Tell us, or check the Corrections page.

More in NCAA

View all

Get the newsletter

Liked this one? Get the next one in your inbox.

Join 10,000+ readers. Unsubscribe anytime.